Not sure what CMSP is but I doubt they know better than the manufacturers. Keep in mind, like with most things, degradation occurs over time. In other words, whether they say it's 2 years or 5 years, it doesn't mean that up to that point everything is fine, and then as soon as it goes over it's crap. A 1-day old tire is better than a 1 year old, which is better than a 2-year old, which is better than 3, and 4 and so on. I've talked to some really fast guys who have ridden on race tires that are 3-4 years old and they said it's fine but don't expect to get the most grip. They won't be like a brand new tire. If you want to be competitive in a MotoAmerica race, an old tire isn't going to get you there, but for track days, they might be fine depending on your pace. There is a reason why some of the really fast guys that fight for wins in national races change out their tires after 1 race. Even though it might still have 80% life, they're not getting the same amount of grip of a new one and that might cost them half a second a lap. For most of us, that's not a big deal, but when you're trying to win races, that could be the difference between winning and getting 3rd or 4th.