The word "better" and "sound" is so arbitrary that no one can make a convincing argument. I have a friend who has the S1R slip on while I have the Black Series. Both are carbon fiber, both sound quite similar although I think the Black Series sounds a bit deeper in tone, and if you get the carbon fiber, it comes down to preference of style. I like the carbon fiber weaving pattern of the Black Series more than the S1R but I like the endcap to the S1R a bit more. Again, preference.
Look at some pictures and videos and see what you like. They are quite loud, up there with the loudest slip ons available so if you don't want to wake up the entire neighborhood, you may want to get a Yoshi or something else that's not as loud or spend $35 on a baffle/P1x silencer.